Filter by Categories
Does I John 5:7-8 Support the Trinity Doctrine?
Bible Study by Martin G. CollinsIn the New King James Version, I John 5:7-8 states: For there are three that bear witness in heaven: the Father, the Word, and the Holy Spirit; and these three are one. And there are three that bear witness on earth: the Spirit, the water, and the blood; and these three agree as one. The Holy Bible teaches that the God Family currently consists of two fully divine Beings, God the Father and God the Son. However, in four popular translations—the King James, the New King James, the New Living Bible, and the Amplified Bible Classic—I John 5:7-8 appears to include additional verbiage not found in most other translations, which seems to introduce a third distinct Being, the Holy Spirit. This added language, italicized in the New King James Version, is not supported by the majority of ancient manuscripts. According to historical accounts, this troubling language was inserted by individuals in the ancient Church who believed the New Testament lacked direct support for their favored view, and it later appeared in late Greek manuscripts due to ecclesiastical pressure on Erasmus to include it in his 1522 Greek New Testament. Additionally, its presence in the Latin Bible likely stems from a scribe incorporating a marginal comment into the text. This deceptive addition to I John 5:7-8, a passage focused on proving the authenticity of Jesus Christ as the Messiah and identifying key characteristics of His true disciples, is seen as an attempt to overshadow a major precept of faith by introducing a false third Being into the God Family.
Misconceptions and Malarkey About the Holy Spirit (Part Two)
'Ready Answer' by David F. MaasThe Trinity is not taught in Scripture, and its defenders prove far less than they claim. Trinitarians lump all non-Trinitarians together as Arians, then spend their effort proving the Son's divinity as though that settled the matter. Non-Trinitarians do not deny a plurality in the God Family. Elohim in Genesis 1:1 is plural, but plural does not mean three, and the singular verb baru shows the Persons acting as one. Establishing that the Son is divine does not automatically yield a three-headed Trinity. The Catholic Fathers wrapped the doctrine in paradox, abstraction, and "mystery," which kept the uninitiated dependent on them and left the doctrine unclear. The proof texts for the Holy Spirit's personality fail on their own evidence. The Spirit speaks Christ's message, not its own, and Christ, not the Spirit, is our intercessor. Scripture describes the Holy Spirit as God's power and essence of mind, poured out, anointing, flowing like rivers of living water, and given as the mind of Christ and inner strength. Just as man has a spirit giving mind and will, God's Spirit is not another personality but the power by which He accomplishes His will and brings believers into His family as sons.
The Trinity and the Holy Spirit (Part Two)
Sermon by John W. Ritenbaugh (1932-2023)The Trinity is false. Elohim is the God kind, a family-kingdom now made up of two distinct personalities, the Father and the Son, who work in complete harmony. The Father is greater than the Son, and the Son always does what pleases the Father. So they are neither co-equal nor co-mingled, and the Athanasian Creed's claim of three co-equal, co-eternal persons fails. When Jesus claimed equality with God, the Jews understood Him to mean the same kind, and He never named anyone in the God family but the Father and Himself. The Trinity was not taught by the apostles. It entered the Church through the Council of Nicaea in AD 325, a product of theologians and philosophers who reasoned it into existence and read it into Scripture. It remains a confusing mass of words that admittedly cannot be understood. The Holy Spirit is the power of God, which emanates from the Father and Son. It is called the power of the Highest, and it is poured out, falls on people, fills a house, and is likened to wind, water, and oil. In every apostolic greeting, and in passages on inheritance, headship, mediation, and the Kingdom, only the Father and Son appear, and the Holy Spirit is never named as a personality. Personal pronouns for the Spirit come from mistranslation. The Greek pneuma is neuter, so the pronouns in John 14:26 and 16:13-14 should read "it." Scripture also gives human actions to inanimate things, so a spirit that testifies or guides does not make it a person.
The Trinity and the Holy Spirit (Part One)
Sermon by John W. Ritenbaugh (1932-2023)For nearly sixty years, the Worldwide Church of God faced little controversy over the nature of God, despite opposition from those who criticized our rejection of the trinity. However, in mid-1993, a doctrinal paper titled "God Is . . ." shifted the church's position from viewing God as a family to embracing the trinity, causing significant upheaval. The trinity is often described as the central doctrine of the Christian church, with many other doctrines revolving around and supporting it. The trinity doctrine is filled with vain babblings about words, lacking clear biblical foundation. In contrast, understanding the term Elohim, a plural term meaning mighty ones and used frequently in Scripture, provides a foundation to see that the trinity cannot possibly align with biblical truth. Elohim, appearing over 2,300 times starting in Genesis 1:1, indicates more than one being, directly challenging the trinity concept. The trinity is presented as an inexplicable mystery, with some asserting that attempting to fully understand it risks losing one's mind, while denying it risks losing one's soul. This notion of mystery arises because the trinity does not fit within the biblical context, leading to speculation rather than solid scriptural proof. The Catholic Encyclopedia admits that neither the Old Testament nor the New Testament contains clear teachings or single statements affirming the trinity, revealing that the doctrine was developed through human deduction and Christological speculation. Historically, the trinity faced resistance within the Catholic Church, taking 126 years of dispute after the Nicene Council in AD 325 to be officially accepted in AD 451, indicating its absence from clear biblical support. Even unconverted individuals with honesty toward Scripture could not accept it initially. The trinity's introduction into Christianity was influenced by pagan trinities, with efforts made to align this false doctrine with the Bible by inventing a third co-equal personality, resulting in an incomprehensible mystery unacceptable to a true child of God. Scriptures such as John 14:28, where Jesus states that the Father is greater than He, directly contradict the idea of co-equality within the trinity, showing the Father and Son as separate personalities in complete agreement but with the Father holding greater authority. No mention of a third personality like the Holy Spirit appears in these contexts of authority, further undermining the trinity concept.
The Holy Spirit and the Trinity (Part Five)
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughThe concept of the Trinity is addressed with a focus on the relationship between the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit as described in the scriptures. Paul uses phrases like Christ in us and Spirit in us, strongly implying the Father as though they are one and the same in context. Jesus declared to the Pharisees and His disciples that He and the Father are one, indicating two personalities united in mind, heart, purpose, perspective, attitude, and spirit, which is the Holy Spirit. They share these qualities in perfect harmony and desire to share them with us to achieve that same harmony. However, this unity does not necessitate a third person in a supposed Trinity dividing themselves to inhabit each of us physically. Just as characteristics of significant persons in a child's life manifest without physical inhabitation, the Father and Son dwell in us through the transfer of their characteristics as we yield to them. The notion of a third person in a Trinity running around inside us is rejected, emphasizing that "in" expresses closeness of relationship, not physical location. The Holy Spirit is not a third person who divides himself to be in many people simultaneously, but rather the essence of God's mind, pure and transcendent, producing abundant and everlasting life. This essence of God's mind, the Holy Spirit, takes up residence in our minds through words and experiences in our relationship with God, directly working to create us in His image. It includes concepts, vision, attitudes, perspectives, and attributes like love, joy, and peace that guide and empower us to conduct life as God would and to glorify Him. There is no third person in a Trinity; the Holy Spirit is simply the essence of God's mind, representing the Father or Son working on our behalf.
The Holy Spirit and the Trinity (Part One)
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughThe doctrine of the Trinity is presented as the central tenet of the Christian religion, emphasizing the unity of the Godhead with three distinct persons: the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. It is acknowledged as a mystery that presupposes divine revelation, remaining partially hidden even when accepted as part of the divine message. Historical accounts suggest that an unqualified Trinitarianism emerged only in the last quadrant of the fourth century, long after the period of Christian origin, indicating that the doctrine was a product of centuries of development rather than an immediate reflection of early Christian consciousness. Contemporary scholarship reveals an unsteady silhouette of Trinitarian discussions, with a growing recognition among exegetes and theologians that Trinitarianism in the New Testament requires serious qualification. The term 'Trinity' itself is not biblical, and defining it as a doctrine of one true God in three co-eternal and co-equal persons relies on the principle that the sense of Scripture, rather than its explicit words, justifies such an unbiblical expression. This doctrine is described as purely revealed, undiscoverable by natural reason, with no analogies in nature or human experience to aid comprehension. In the Old Testament, there is no clear revelation of the Trinity, and it is a plain fact that reliance solely on Old Testament revelation has never led to this doctrine. Recent interpretations lean on the underlying suggestion of a three-fold cause in the organism of Old Testament revelation rather than specific texts. In the New Testament, the doctrine is not explicitly taught but rather presupposed or overheard in scriptural statements, appearing as already complete without traces of developmental growth. The doctrine's mysterious nature is further defined by the Vatican Council as a truth beyond human discovery without divine revelation, remaining veiled even after acceptance. It is admitted that the doctrine of the Trinity is impenetrable to reason, a point reinforced by various sources indicating its incomprehensibility. Additionally, it is noted that liberal Protestantism today rejects the Trinity, contending it was formulated in the second century and finalized in the fourth century due to historical controversies. Contrary to the Trinitarian view, it is asserted that God is not a closed Trinitarian Godhead but a Family, with the Father and the Son as central figures, using familial analogies to convey this relationship. The Holy Spirit is not a third person in a Trinity but is described as the essence of the mind of the Father and the Son, directly influencing believers. Scriptures are cited to show that the Father Himself, not a third entity, works in and through Jesus Christ and believers, emphasizing a direct and personal relationship without the involvement of a separate Trinitarian person.
The Holy Spirit and the Trinity (Part Four)
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughThe material addresses the Trinity concept while explaining how God empowers individuals for His purposes through His Spirit. When describing the skills given to Bezaleel, Aholiab, and other craftsmen for the tabernacle, the presentation questions whether this required a supposed third person of a Trinity to divide and physically inhabit each person. Such an idea is rejected as unnecessary and inconsistent with the biblical pattern of spirit as an invisible, immaterial activating power that can be communicated without physical location inside a person. The same principle appears in the accounts of Samson receiving strength and in the casting out of demons, where supernatural effects occur through spirit without any indication of a separate divine person entering the individual. Instead, the Father and the Son directly impart power, wisdom, or influence as needed, producing good fruit within their purpose. This understanding connects to the broader teaching that spirit involves mind, attitude, and relationship. Just as parents transmit characteristics to children without literally residing inside them, God transmits His mind and ways through His Spirit by means of words, prayer, and time spent together. The result is transformation into the image of the divine family without requiring a third person to indwell believers.
The Holy Spirit and the Trinity (Part Six)
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughThe material presents the Trinity as a misunderstanding that must be rejected in favor of the biblical revelation that God is a family consisting solely of the Father and the Son. This understanding arises directly from the ongoing work of transferring the essence of God's mind into human minds through both words and direct divine action. When Scripture states that it is God who works in believers both to will and to do, the reference is to the Father and the Son acting as the Holy Spirit frequently mentioned in the New Testament. No third person exists within a trinity to close off the Godhead from future entrance by the saints. Instead, God is a family of immortal, creating, governing Beings who possess form and are composed of spirit. The Father Himself raises His family, personally overseeing the process of conversion and growth rather than delegating it to any separate entity. This truth supports the broader message that conversion transforms human minds by infusing them with the Father's and the Son's own wisdom, understanding, knowledge, and attitudes, enabling believers to carry out His will within the church and to develop an intimate relationship with Him.
The Holy Spirit and the Trinity (Part Two)
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughThe material addresses the Trinity in connection with the rejection of divine truth and the resulting complexity in religious understanding. It notes that reference works such as the Catholic Encyclopedia state the Old Testament contains nothing about any trinity. The same sources indicate that the New Testament remains vague on the subject, leading to a doctrine constructed from what is described as the sense of Scripture and, in one case, Christological speculation. This process of construction is presented as an admission that the teaching rests on human reasoning rather than explicit biblical statement. The discussion links this development to the broader theme that spirit constitutes the decisive element in the salvation process. Just as mankind suppresses available truth about God as Creator and Lawgiver, religious systems influenced by an alien spirit transform the simplicity that is in Christ into elaborate doctrines. The Trinity serves as an illustration of how rejection of straightforward revelation produces division and denominational fragmentation, even among those possessing portions of biblical truth. This pattern underscores the need for God's Spirit to replace the deceptive spirit at work in the world, enabling acceptance and application of what is plainly revealed rather than speculative additions.
Whither the Holy Spirit?
CGG Weekly by Richard T. RitenbaughThere is no Third Person in the God family, and the epistles' salutations make this point implicitly. In twenty epistles from five apostles (not counting Hebrews), grace, mercy, and peace come only from God the Father and the Lord Jesus Christ, and never from the Holy Spirit. Because the omission is total rather than occasional, it is no mistake, slight, or embarrassing oversight. The Father and the Son are the only divine Persons, and they alone send personal greetings to the church. The Holy Spirit, not being an additional, distinct entity, sends none. Jesus explains the correct understanding in John 14: the Holy Spirit is not another personality but the divine essence of both the Father and the Son, which comes to reside in each of God's chosen sons and daughters. Paul says plainly, "the Lord is the Spirit" (II Corinthians 3:17), and equates the Spirit's intercession (Romans 8:26) with Christ's (Romans 8:34). The "Christ in you" statements carry the same sense. Broadly, the Spirit is the personality, mind, and power of God to do His will throughout creation. For believers, it is the means by which the Father and the Son live in them, empower them, and unite them with themselves, as Jesus prays in John 17:20-23. Since the Father and the Son are fully united, Christ in us means the Father is in us too, so there is no need for a Trinity.
What Does It Mean to 'Walk in the Spirit'?
Sermonette by David C. GrabbeIf fleshly things become more important, we are on a trajectory toward death. We must exercise control, drawing on the power of God's Spirit.
The Holy Spirit
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughTheologians, misapplying grammatical gender and personification, falsely deduce a phantom third person, propped up by a spurious insertion (I John 5:7-8).
The Father-Son Relationship (Part Eight)
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughJesus Christ and God the Father are one in spirit and purpose, purposing to draw us toward that same kind of unity that currently exists between them.
God Is . . . What?
Booklet by John W. RitenbaughWhat is God's nature? Is God one Being? Two? Three? Bible students have long searched for the answers to these questions. The truth is both simple and profound.
Misconceptions and Malarkey About the Holy Spirit (Part One)
'Ready Answer' by David F. MaasThe Trinity, the claim that God is one yet three, has no biblical support and is a late, pagan-rooted doctrine. The word trinitas was coined by Tertullian more than a century after Christ, and the Cappadocian Fathers (Basil, Gregory of Nyssa, Gregory Nazianzus) formulated it, with approval at Constantinople in AD 382. Before then no group following Christ seriously considered it. Its roots lie in Babylonian idolatry, whose triad of Nimrod, Semiramis, and Tammuz reappears in Egyptian, Greek, Roman, Hindu, and Scandinavian forms. Christ contradicted the idea of equality among the three when He said, "The Father is greater than I" (John 14:28). Constantine, interested in political unity rather than pure doctrine, presided at Nicea. The supposed proofs rest on strained inferences and crude analogies such as water, eggs, and shamrocks. The masculine pronoun for the Comforter reflects Greek grammatical gender, not personality, and the neuter pneuma is rightly rendered "itself." In Luke and Acts, pneuma hagion appears without the article, indicating an essence or power rather than an entity. Matthew 28:19 merely lists Father, Son, and Spirit, and 1 John 5:7-8 is a spurious later insertion. The Holy Spirit is the spirit and mind of Christ, the instrument of regeneration and a down payment on the life to come (Ephesians 1:13-14). A closed Trinity would bar believers from becoming God's children. Satan, who hates to see God's Family enlarged, benefits most from the doctrine.
What Is the Holy Spirit?
'Ready Answer' by David C. GrabbeEven theologians admit that the Holy Spirit is a mystery to them. Yet the confusion comes from pagan thought patterns that have affected how Scripture is read.
The Nature of God: Elohim
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughUnderstanding Elohim teaches us about the nature of God and where our lives are headed. Elohim refers to a plural family unit in the process of expanding.
The Father-Son Relationship (Part Four)
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughThe Trinity doctrine, which makes the Godhead three co-equal, like-estate beings, is false, and so is ditheism, its two-being alternative, because the Son is not part of the Godhead. The Father alone is the Absolute Deity and sole Head of all, so much so that He is the God of the Son. Jesus Himself said He had a God, both in the flesh (Matthew 27:46) and after His resurrection as spirit (John 20:17). Paul confirms that the head of Christ is God (I Corinthians 11:3), that the Father is the God of our Lord Jesus Christ (Ephesians 1:17-22), and that the Father sent the Son (Galatians 4:4). Father and Son are equal only in being of the same God-kind, not in function and responsibility. One is Head and the other submissive. Creation shows no two-headed thing, and God's order allows only one Head. The translation "Godhead" in Acts 17:29 and Colossians 2:9 wrongly implies a Trinity. The Greek words mean divine nature or Deity, and Colossians 2:9 says Christ perfectly expressed the Deity. Christ is the Complement of the Father, completing His revelation. He cannot be His own complement, so the Father and Son are two distinct Beings, not a three-in-one.
Strategies for Interfacing with Babylon without Becoming Assimilated (Part Five)
Sermon by David F. MaasGod is not a closed triangular Trinity, but a family consisting of God the Father and God the Son, and will include billions of resurrected, glorified saints.
The Father-Son Relationship (Part Seven)
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughThe Holy Spirit is never venerated as a separate being. Our hope is the indwelling of Christ, used interchangeably with 'Spirit of God' and 'Spirit of Truth.'
The Father-Son Relationship (Part One)
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughThe Father is the source of everything and the Son is the channel through which He carries out His purpose. Jesus declared that the Father is superior to Him.
God the Father in the Old Testament
Sermon by Richard T. RitenbaughThe Hebrew Scriptures reveal the existence of the Father. Deuteronomy 6:4 refers to God as one, signifying unity of purpose and identical character.
The Holy Spirit
Sermonette byGod's Holy Spirit typically refers to the mind of God and Christ, which is added to our human spirit to create a sound mind by which we witness of God.
Lying to the Holy Spirit
'Ready Answer' by Richard T. RitenbaughThe apostle Peter claims Ananias and Sapphira lied to the Holy Spirit. Does his statement prove the Holy Spirit is a divine Person in a Trinity?
God the Father (Part 1)
Sermon by Martin G. CollinsJesus reveals that the Father has always had supreme authority, and that He and His Father are absolutely at one in purpose. We must conform to their image.
Post-Historic Cave-Dwellers
'Prophecy Watch' by Charles WhitakerThe Sixth Seal of Revelation details the reaction of some people to the amazing heavenly signs they witness, giving us insight into what lies ahead.
Grieving the Holy Spirit
Sermon by Richard T. RitenbaughJust as our human spirit can be grieved, God is grieved by willful sinful behavior—sullying, suppressing, or stifling the Spirit that identifies us as His.
The Father-Son Relationship (Part Five)
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughAlthough Christ is not the Absolute Deity, He is nevertheless the complement of the Father. He had a pre-existence as the God of the Old Testament.
The Father-Son Relationship (Part Two)
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughChrist Himself asserted the superiority of the Father. Jesus serves as the revelator of the great God, providing the only means of access to Him.
The Helper and the Angel of the Lord
Sermonette by David C. GrabbeChrist frequently used 3rd person titles, such as the Son of Man and the Helper. Just as Christ sent the Helper—Himself—so Yahweh sent His Angel—Himself.
Image and Likeness of God (Part Two)
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughJesus did not take on a different shape or form when He was transfigured. Taking on the image of the heavenly does not vaporize one into shapeless essence.
The Father-Son Relationship (Part Three)
Sermon by John W. RitenbaughThe Father and Son are separate; the Father is the source of all power, while the Son serves as the channel through which we interface with the Father.
Announcing . . . Christ's Birth!
Sermon by Richard T. RitenbaughThe blending of paganism with inspired Scripture has degraded and obscured the meaning and glory of what happened in the announcement of Jesus Christ's birth.
The Holy Spirit: The Power of God
Sermon by Kim MyersThe Trinity is false doctrine, and rejecting it is one of the five signs of God's true church. The Holy Spirit is not a third being or another person but the power and mind of God. The Bible shows this plainly: the Spirit hovered over the waters at creation, and God sends it forth and pours it out. A person cannot be poured out or dwell inside us, but God's power and a little of His mind can. Christ calls the Spirit the Helper that will be in us, and through it God lives in us as we keep His commandments. Those who are called, repent, live by every word of God, and are baptized receive this gift. It opens our minds to God's laws and doctrines, intercedes for us in prayer, produces the fruit of the Spirit, and gives us eternal life. When the Worldwide Church of God introduced the "God Is" doctrine, which was simply the Trinity, thirty leaders watched a video explaining it and none had enough understanding of the Holy Spirit or enough of the armor of God to say it was wrong. Confusion over this doctrine left them vulnerable, and many of them have since left the church and are spiritually dead. Understanding the true nature of the Holy Spirit protects believers from the Trinity and from Satan's deceptions.
The God of Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, and Moses
Sermonette by David C. GrabbeThe identical actions of the Lord and the Angel of the Lord show they are the same Being. The God known by Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, and Moses was Jesus Christ.
Jesus on the Holy Spirit
Sermon by Richard T. RitenbaughJesus taught about the Holy Spirit's function to carry out God's work, including inspiring one to speak the words of God and to resist the power of Satan.