The sixth commandment distinguishes intentional killing, true murder, from accidental death, or manslaughter. Drawing from Exodus 21:12-14 and Numbers 35:9-32, killing falls into only two categories, accidental and intentional, with self-defense conspicuously absent as a legitimate classification. Accidental death occurs without intent, awareness, or premeditation, as illustrated by an axe head slipping and killing a neighbor. Though not incurring the death penalty, manslaughter still demanded serious consequence, requiring the guilty person to flee to a city of refuge until the high priest's death. This system reflects the sanctity of life, which God alone controls. It also carries spiritual significance, for the high priest parallels Christ, whose death releases the guilty and provides refuge, hope, and forgiveness. Also see Bible verses for Death, Accidental.

Playlist:

playlist Go to the Death, Accidental (topic) playlist

Filter by Categories

The Sixth Commandment

Bible Study by Martin G. Collins

Accidental killing is not murder. Under the original letter of the law, the sixth commandment forbade intentional killing, and God distinguished the person who kills deliberately from the one who kills without intent (Exodus 21:12-14; Numbers 35:9-32). The one who killed accidentally was not put to death as a murderer. Even so, manslaughter is a horrible crime and carried real consequences. The culprit had to remain in a city of refuge until the high priest died, so the life lost was not treated lightly even when no malice was involved.

Does Scripture Allow for Killing in Self-Defense?

'Ready Answer' by David C. Grabbe

God recognizes only two classifications of killing: accidental and intentional (Numbers 35:9-28). A death is accidental when there is no intent to kill or harm and no awareness that an action will result in another's death. Deuteronomy 19:5 gives the clear example of a man cutting timber with his neighbor whose ax head slips from the handle and strikes and kills the neighbor. Such a death is not murder. By contrast, when there is intent to kill or injure, God's law defines it as murder regardless of what the other person was threatening or doing (Exodus 21:12). Firing a gun with foreknowledge that it could kill is therefore murder; self-defense is a category granted by the law of the land, not by God's law. The same distinction explains Exodus 22:2-3. A thief killed while breaking in at night is not avenged by guilt because in the dark it is hard to judge how much force is needed to restrain an unknown intruder, so the homeowner is given the benefit of the doubt that he did not deliberately use lethal force. If the sun has risen and nothing hinders his judgment, the killing is intentional and he is guilty of murder. Christ's teaching that murder begins in the heart confirms that accidental versus intentional rests on what is in the heart.

Murder by Degrees

Sermonette by James Beaubelle

God's called-out ones must curtail 'installment plan' serial sins which carry them to a fatal point of no return.

Hope and Refuge (Part Two)

CGG Weekly by Mike Ford

Under the ancient system governing manslaughter, accidental death carried severe consequences even though no malicious intent existed. Exodus 21:12 declares plainly that a man who takes another's life must be put to death, yet the following verse provides an exception when the killing was unintentional and not premeditated. A hypothetical scenario illustrates this: two men enter a forest to cut firewood, and when the head of one man's axe flies off its handle, it strikes and kills his friend. Though clearly accidental, in a society without an established judicial system, there was no automatic way to prove innocence. The responsibility for addressing such a death fell to the "avenger of blood," the nearest male relative of the victim, who bore a moral obligation to protect his kinsman's property, liberty, and posterity, and to avenge his death on an eye-for-an-eye basis. This avenger held the power of life and death, and his diligence in pursuit could determine whether the one responsible for the accidental death was caught and killed. The only recourse for the man who caused the death was to flee immediately to the nearest city of refuge. There, he could present evidence that the killing was not premeditated. If believed, he would be permitted to live safely within that city, free from retribution, but only until the death of the high priest serving in Jerusalem at that time. Should he leave the city before that point for any reason, the avenger of blood retained the right to find and kill him. This scenario carries spiritual significance. Although one might initially imagine Satan as a blood avenger relentlessly pursuing people toward death, the role actually corresponds more accurately to Christ, who has been given all judgment in heaven and on earth and who will ensure that justice is ultimately brought upon those who mistreat His people. Revelation 6:10 confirms this connection, depicting a cry for the Lord to judge and avenge the blood of the slain. The high priest also serves as a parallel to Christ, since his death released those guilty of manslaughter from the penalty they faced. The emotional weight of this system offers a picture of hope rather than despair. The horror, guilt, and grief of having accidentally taken a life would be compounded by the sudden realization of incurring a death penalty and needing to flee for survival. Yet hope exists in reaching the city of refuge safely, and beyond that, in the eventual freedom and forgiveness granted through the death of the high priest, whose death clears the fugitive of wrongdoing and stays the hand of the executioner. This mirrors what Christ has accomplished through His own death, providing the means by which the path toward refuge and hope has been made secure for those who flee to lay hold of it.

The Sixth Commandment

'Personal' from John W. Ritenbaugh

Accidental killing is distinguished from premeditated murder. Exodus 21:12-14 separates the man who lies in wait or acts with treachery from the one who did not lie in wait but whom God delivered the victim into the hand of. The premeditated murderer is taken even from God's altar to die, while the accidental killer is given a place to flee. Even so, no money or property settlement can atone for the destruction of the image of God in a slain person, so the accidental killer still must flee to a city of refuge. Numbers 35:9-34 provides six such cities, three on each side of the Jordan. The killer receives a trial there, and if found guilty only of accidental death, he must remain in the city until the current high priest dies. The city serves as his jail, yet he is free to move about, find work, and live with and support his family. If he leaves, the avenger of blood, usually a relative of the victim charged with protecting the family's rights, may lawfully kill him. The Hebrew word for avenger, go'el, also means redeemer, as Boaz was for Ruth. Legal safeguards throughout Scripture protect life, requiring careful inquiry and multiple witnesses.

Handwriting on the Wall: Without Natural Affection

Feast of Tabernacles Sermon by Richard T. Ritenbaugh

Narcissism and self-centeredness have snuffed out out-going concern, and everyone does what is right in their own eyes as the love of many grows cold.

The Sixth Commandment (Part One) (1997)

'Personal' from John W. Ritenbaugh

Our society is becoming increasingly violent. The sixth of the Ten Commandments covers crime, capital punishment, murder, hatred, revenge and war.

The Commandments (Part Fifteen)

Sermon/Bible Study by John W. Ritenbaugh

Jesus emphasized the spirit of the law, which places deterrents on the motive (anger, resentment, envy, revenge), preventing murder from ever taking place.

Refuge! Refuge! (Part One)

Feast of Tabernacles Sermon by Martin G. Collins

The cities of refuge highlight the great importance God placed on the sanctity of life, especially in beings created in God's image.

Forms vs. Spirituality (Part 2)

Sermon by John W. Ritenbaugh

Sins committed presumptuously by people of high responsibility (leaders) are judged more rigorously than those sins committed by people in ignorance.

Refuge! Refuge! (Part Two)

Feast of Tabernacles Sermon by Martin G. Collins

Realizing that men are prone to mistakes, God commanded the Israelites to have six cities of refuge to protect those who accidentally committed manslaughter.