Heaven, as Paradise, is in the presence of God's throne, identified as the third heaven and linked to the New Jerusalem, where the tree of life stands. It is not yet complete, awaiting descent after the Millennium, so the repentant malefactor has not entered it. Hell, often misunderstood, is not a place of eternal torment but signifies the grave (sheol, hades) or complete destruction (gehenna, Lake of Fire). Scriptures confirm the wages of sin as death, not eternal suffering, with the wicked facing annihilation in the second death, reduced to ashes. Death brings unconsciousness, awaiting resurrection and judgment, where eternal life is a gift, not inherent. Also see Bible verses for Heaven/Hell Doctrine.

Playlist:

playlist Go to the Heaven/Hell Doctrine (topic) playlist

Filter by Categories

Did the Thief on the Cross Go to Heaven with Jesus Christ (Luke 23:43)?

Bible Questions & Answers

Jesus said He would be in the grave 3 days and 3 nights after His crucifixion. Given that, could the thief have been with Christ in Paradise that very day?

Is There a Hell?

Herbert W. Armstrong Booklet

The common belief in the Western world portrays hell as a place of eternal torture by fire, yet the original meaning of the word "hell" in old English referred merely to a covered hole in the ground, a dark and silent grave. The Greek word "gehenna," often translated as hell, signifies a place of destruction and death, not ongoing torment. Jesus, speaking to Jews familiar with Gehenna as the Valley of Hinnom, used it to illustrate complete destruction by fire, leaving nothing but ashes. The Bible, in Romans 6:23, declares the wages of sin to be death, not eternal life in torture, emphasizing that eternal life is God's gift, not an inherent possession. The punishment described is eternal death, the second death, from which there is no resurrection, not an endless process of punishing. Jesus referred to the lake of fire as the place of this final punishment, aligning with Revelation 20:14, which identifies it as the second death. This lake of fire, far hotter than any imagined inferno, is a place of destruction, not eternal life in agony. Jesus explicitly stated in Matthew 10:28 that both soul and body could be destroyed in Gehenna, reinforcing it as a site of utter annihilation. Scriptures such as Malachi 4:1-3 depict a day when the wicked will be burned up completely, reduced to ashes underfoot, with no root or branch remaining. Similarly, Jude 7 describes Sodom and Gomorrah suffering eternal fire, yet they are not still burning, indicating eternal destruction, not perpetual torment. Isaiah 66:24 speaks of unquenched fire and undying worms, yet this symbolizes complete consumption, as demonstrated by unquenched fires in history, like Jerusalem's burning, which eventually ceased. The doctrine of resurrection to judgment contradicts the notion of immediate eternal torture at death. Revelation 20:13-15 shows death and hell giving up their dead for judgment, after which those not found in the book of life are cast into the lake of fire, the second death, confirming the finality of destruction rather than ongoing suffering. God's nature as both love and justice opposes the idea of eternal torment, aligning instead with the biblical portrayal of the wicked being cut off, consumed, and reduced to nothingness, as seen in Psalms 37 and 104.

Heaven Must Wait

Sermon/Bible Study by Richard T. Ritenbaugh

The common notion of heaven includes streets of gold and heavenly mansions prepared by Jesus, where individuals can pursue leisure activities like golfing, painting, or playing musical instruments. Some envision heaven as a place to interact with biblical figures or to earn wings to become guardian angels. Others imagine engaging in heavenly battles against evil forces. The Catholic concept of heaven involves the beatific vision, eternally enjoying God's presence, or envisioning cherubic figures on clouds. These ideas reflect a human desire to transfer earthly pleasures and lifestyles into a heavenly setting, which is fundamentally a pagan concept spiritualized into a Christian context. The Bible, however, indicates that these notions are incorrect. It states that no human eye or ear has seen or heard what God has prepared for those who love Him, except for those who have received God's Spirit. Even then, the understanding is limited, as seen through a mirror darkly. The text emphasizes that the afterlife is not as commonly imagined but involves a greater purpose beyond these human conceptions.

God's Plan and the False Immortal Soul Doctrine

'Ready Answer' by Craig Sablich

Scripture is silent about an innate, immortal soul that goes to heaven at death. Man is mortal, and immortality is a gift added from outside him; only Christ now possesses it. At death the body returns to dust as animals' bodies do, and the human spirit, which gives understanding but has no life or sentience of its own, returns to God. The dead are described as sleeping, and they await resurrection. Jesus called Lazarus dead, not alive in heaven. Peter says David is dead and buried and "did not ascend into the heavens." The only voice that implies man cannot die is the serpent's "You shall not surely die." After the Fall, God barred man from the Tree of Life so that he would not live forever, so eternal life comes only through God's Spirit. Hebrews 9:27 sets the pattern of one death followed by judgment. Believers receive immortality in the first resurrection at Christ's return and reign with Him a thousand years. The rest of humanity is raised in the second resurrection to learn God's way and be judged. Those who knowingly reject Him are raised in a third resurrection and cast into the lake of fire. This is the second death, a final and irrevocable end, not eternal torment, since the wages of sin is death.

Basic Doctrines: The Fate of the Wicked

Bible Study by Earl L. Henn

The wages of sin is death, not eternal torment, so unrepentant sinners die rather than live forever in a fiery hell. At death the righteous and the wicked alike, like the animals, return to dust, know nothing, and feel neither joy nor pain, so no one goes to heaven or hell at death. Both groups are raised in the resurrection and judged (John 5:28-29). Jesus' word for hell, Gehenna, means the Valley of Hinnom, the refuse-burning valley south of Jerusalem, which He used as a type of the place of final punishment. An unquenchable fire does not burn forever; it burns until everything is consumed and then goes out, as with the fire God kindled in Jerusalem's gates (Jeremiah 17:27) and the fires of Hinnom. The wicked, having died once, are cast into the Lake of Fire and die the second death. Body, mind and spirit are utterly destroyed, and they cease to exist, leaving only ashes under the feet of the righteous (Malachi 4:1, 3). Afterward only the righteous remain alive, and they live eternally. A loving God does not consign billions to endless torture.

Pope Francis Questions Hell

Commentary by Richard T. Ritenbaugh

Hell is not an ever-burning torment, and the unrepentant do not suffer conscious punishment forever. Those who refuse to repent will be burned up in the Lake of Fire, and their souls will disappear in fire. That is close to what Pope Francis reportedly told Scalfari, that sinful souls simply disappear, though the Vatican denies the quotation was faithful. The Catholic Church has long taught the opposite. Its catechism affirms that hell exists and is eternal, that souls dying in mortal sin descend at once into eternal fire, and that every person has a spiritual, immortal soul. Benedict XVI likewise said hell exists and is eternal for those who close their hearts to Christ's love. Cardinal Nichols takes a middle road, saying Catholic teaching never names anyone as being in hell and that the fire-and-brimstone imagery belongs to church iconography, not doctrine. These men are publicly wrestling with real holes in the doctrines of hell and the soul's immortality, but they lack God's Spirit and the courage to follow the truth through. Teaching the truth about hell and the soul would force them to dismantle nearly all fundamental Catholic belief, because the doctrine of the soul's immortality especially holds up the rest like a house of cards. For that reason the church has relied on an enforcing body, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the successor to the Inquisition, to hold everyone to the same doctrines.

Disproving Hell

Sermon/Bible Study by Richard T. Ritenbaugh

In examining the doctrine of Heaven and Hell, a critical perspective emerges that challenges conventional beliefs about hell as an ever-burning place of torment. The discussion focuses on three distinct arguments—lexical, prophetic, and theological—to refute the modern Protestant and Catholic views of hell. The lexical argument centers on the original meanings of biblical words associated with hell. In the Old Testament, the Hebrew word "sheol" appears 66 times, fundamentally meaning a hole, pit, or grave—a place where dead bodies are placed, not a realm of afterlife torment. Its evolution to broader, mystical interpretations as a place of the dead or void came later, influenced by external cultures like Babylon and Greece, but the Old Testament retains the concrete sense of a burial place. Examples from Psalms, Numbers, and Jonah illustrate "sheol" as a grave or pit, whether a literal hole in the ground or the belly of a fish, always tied to the physical destination of the deceased, devoid of any notion of conscious afterlife. In the New Testament, the Greek term "hades" mirrors "sheol," used only 10 times and signifying the state or abode of the dead, essentially the grave, with no indication of consciousness or purgatory. Passages in Matthew, Acts, and Revelation reinforce this, linking "hades" with death and the grave, not a place of eternal suffering. Another Greek term, "tartaroo," a verb meaning to cast down, appears once in II Peter, relating to the restraint of sinning angels on earth, not humans, and thus irrelevant to the doctrine of hell for people. The term "abyss," akin to a bottomless pit, aligns with this concept of restraint but does not denote hell as commonly understood. Finally, "gehenna," used 12 times, refers to the Valley of Hinnom outside Jerusalem, a literal dump where trash and criminal bodies were burned, serving as Jesus Christ's illustration of the Lake of Fire—a place of complete destruction, not ongoing torment. Jeremiah's account ties this valley to God's wrath and total consumption, supporting the idea of annihilation rather than eternal suffering. The prophetic argument aligns with the biblical timeline of God's plan, as depicted in the holy days and Revelation. It shows no place for an eternal hell; instead, those who reject God face the Lake of Fire, resulting in complete destruction, as echoed in Malachi where the wicked are reduced to ashes, not consigned to perpetual torment. The theological argument builds on these foundations, asserting that the Bible consistently teaches death as the penalty for sin, not an immortal soul enduring in hell. From Genesis, God declares that sin leads to death, a concept satan contradicts by promoting the immortality of the soul, which underpins the traditional hell doctrine. Scriptures in Ezekiel, Ecclesiastes, and Psalms affirm that the soul can die, the body disintegrates, and there is no consciousness after death—only a spirit returning to God as a record for resurrection, not a living entity. Romans emphasizes that eternal life is a gift through Jesus Christ, not an inherent trait, negating the need for a hell if souls were immortal. Matthew underscores the fear of God's power to destroy utterly in the Lake of Fire, reinforcing the finality of death over eternal torment. These arguments collectively present hell not as a place of eternal suffering but as the grave or ultimate destruction in the Lake of Fire, aligning with the biblical narrative of death and resurrection rather than an ongoing afterlife of punishment.

God's Wrath and Hell

Sermon by Richard T. Ritenbaugh

God's wrath forms an essential aspect of His holy and righteous character, consistently displayed throughout both testaments as a response to unrelenting sin. Scripture records this anger in the prophets, Psalms, Gospels, epistles, and Revelation, where God promises destruction upon the wicked and unrepentant. Jesus Himself expressed divine wrath, as when He cleared the temple and confronted the Pharisees. Traditional teaching defines hell as a place of eternal conscious punishment where the wicked suffer unending torment. This view draws primarily from the Greek word gehenna, which Jesus employed as a metaphor drawn from Jerusalem's refuse-burning valley. The material explains that gehenna illustrates complete destruction in the Lake of Fire rather than perpetual suffering. The Hebrew sheol and Greek hades denote the grave or state of the dead, with no implication of conscious torment. Tartaroo applies solely to fallen angels placed in restraint. Passages describing unquenchable fire, undying worms, and everlasting punishment indicate final, irreversible judgment that consumes the wicked, not endless torture. The Lake of Fire constitutes the second death, ending life for the incorrigibly wicked after just punishment. This understanding aligns with God's justice and love, which withholds wrath until repentance becomes impossible, then executes decisive destruction so that righteousness alone remains in the new heavens and new earth.

Basic Doctrines: The Reward of the Saved

Bible Study by Earl L. Henn

The reward of the saved is not going to heaven, though most professing Christian churches teach exactly that and most people assume it. The Bible says no such thing, and the popular picture of floating on a cloud and strumming a harp is far short of God's promise. Jesus commands His followers to seek first the kingdom of God, and that Kingdom will be established here on earth. Christ's words in Matthew 5:5, "the meek shall inherit the earth," echo David in Psalm 37:11, and neither says anything about inheriting a mystical place in the heavens. God's promise to Abraham was extended to include the inheritance of the whole world, and true Christians, as Abraham's spiritual descendants, share it. When Jesus uses the phrase "kingdom of heaven," the word "of" shows possession, not location, so it means heaven's kingdom, just as "God's Kingdom" does. It refers to the government Christ will bring from heaven and set up on earth at His return. The resurrected saints will reign on the earth as princes under Christ, teaching and enforcing God's laws during the thousand-year reign. Their ultimate reward after the Millennium is to share in ruling the entire universe as members of the God Family, a destiny far greater than going to heaven.

Does Doctrine Really Matter? (Part Nine)

Sermon by John W. Ritenbaugh

The cosmology of ancient Greece, saturated with astrology and Gnostic dualism, filtered into the doctrines of the early church, creating corrupt doctrines.

Was Enoch Translated to Heaven (Hebrews 11:5)?

Bible Questions & Answers

Enoch was not taken to heaven, as the world commonly claims from Genesis 5:24. That reading contradicts Scripture. Hebrews 9:27 says it is appointed for men to die once, so if Enoch never died, Scripture would contradict itself. Jesus settles the matter in John 3:13: no one has ascended to heaven but He who came down from heaven, and that includes Enoch. Peter confirms in Acts 2:29-34 that even David, a man as great as he was, has not risen to heaven but remains in the grave. Hebrews 11 lists faithful saints who did not receive the promise, so that they would not be made perfect apart from us. Like them, Enoch and many unnamed saints await the resurrection of the dead and glorification in God's Kingdom, not an immediate reward in heaven after death. The word "translated" in Hebrews 11:5 means transferred. God conveyed Enoch from one place on earth to another to escape violence aimed at him, and there he died like all men. Colossians 1:13 uses the same idea for Christians, who are conveyed spiritually into the Kingdom of the Son of God's love.

Death Is Not the End (Part Seven)

CGG Weekly by Richard T. Ritenbaugh

There is life after death; there is an age to come in which all who have not been called to salvation will be raised to new life to hear what God offers.

What Happened to the Thief on the Cross? (Part Two)

CGG Weekly by David C. Grabbe

Because of the widespread belief in an immortal soul, many assume that the thief and Jesus were together after their deaths. The Bible says this cannot be.

God of the Living (2019)

Sermonette by Richard T. Ritenbaugh

Christ's comment in Matthew 22:32 about "the God ... of the living" gives absolutely no mention about a place of the afterlife, but only a condition.

What Happened to the Thief on the Cross? (Part One)

CGG Weekly by David C. Grabbe

Did the criminal crucified next to Christ go to heaven? That is commonly believed—yet even Jesus was not in heaven that day! Digging deeper shows the truth.

What Happened to the Thief on the Cross? (Part Three)

CGG Weekly by David C. Grabbe

If the thief on the cross went to heaven the day that he was crucified, He would he have gone there without Jesus Christ, who was not in Paradise that day!

You Shall Surely Die

Sermonette by Craig Sablich

The belief that humans are inherently immortal and consciously live after death has influenced many cultures and Christian teachings.

Parable of Lazarus and the Rich Man (Part One)

Bible Study by Martin G. Collins

The Parable of Lazarus and the Rich Man illustrates the resurrections from the dead and the Second Death. Knowing the hidden time element is key.

Parable of Lazarus and the Rich Man (Part Two)

Bible Study by Martin G. Collins

Jesus' parable preaches the gospel of the Kingdom by revealing salvation, the resurrection to eternal life, and inheritance of His Kingdom on the earth.

Lazarus and the Rich Man

Sermon/Bible Study by Richard T. Ritenbaugh

The Parable of Lazarus and the Rich Man is often held up as proof of the torments of an ever-burning hell. However, the rest of Scripture gives a clearer picture.

What Is the Second Death?

'Prophecy Watch' by David C. Grabbe

The second death is an event beyond physical death. It disproves the traditional heaven-hell and immortal soul doctrines, yet demonstrates God's perfect justice.

Is Your Soul Immortal?

Sermon/Bible Study by Richard T. Ritenbaugh

The prevailing idea is that the soul is the indestructible part of a human being that lives on after death. The Bible reveals a different reality of life and death.

We Shall Be God

Sermon/Bible Study by John W. Ritenbaugh

Though it may sound pretentious or even blasphemous, God's Word shows that we will become literal offspring of the Eternal God, sharing His name and nature.

Jesus and 'the Spirits in Prison'

'Ready Answer' by Richard T. Ritenbaugh

Peter's statement that Jesus 'preached to the spirits in prison' has baffled many a Bible student. The traditional interpretation is woefully off-base.

Thy Kingdom Come

Sermonette by Ronny H. Graham

Most professing Christians hold to the pagan belief that heaven is the reward of the saved, imagining that they will waft off to heaven at death.

Christ's Death and the 'Immortality' of the Soul

Sermon by John W. Ritenbaugh

The dangerous false belief of inherent immortal life has led to an acceleration of sin and the danger of eternal oblivion. Only God can give eternal life.

Is the Christian Required To Do Works? (Part Five)

'Personal' from John W. Ritenbaugh

Jesus came with a message of salvation, called 'the gospel of the Kingdom of God.' Here is the relationship between the gospel and Christian works.

What Do You Mean . . . Salvation?

Herbert W. Armstrong Booklet

Not one in a hundred knows what salvation is—how to get it or when you will receive it. Don't be too sure you do! Here is the truth, made plain.

Where Are Enoch and Elijah?

Herbert W. Armstrong Booklet

Enoch was translated that he should not see death. Elijah went up by a whirlwind into heaven. Yet the Bible shows they are not in heaven now! Here is what happened.

Do You Recognize This Man? (Part One)

Sermon by Richard T. Ritenbaugh

Would we recognize Jesus Christ based on a description? Just about everybody with whom He came into contact misunderstood Him, including His own disciples.

The Final Harvest

'Personal' from John W. Ritenbaugh

Are millions lost because they never heard the name of Christ? What about infants who died? Are the doors forever shut on those born into false religion?

1 Peter 3:19

Sermonette by Richard T. Ritenbaugh

The idea of purgatory, Hades, or Hell has a long history, predating Christianity by centuries. Roman Catholicism adopted the whole framework into its theology.

Lamentations (Part Three; 1989)

Sermon/Bible Study by John W. Ritenbaugh

As Lamentations opens, Jerusalem is personified as a widow who has had to endure the destruction of her family as well as the mocking scorn from the captors.

The Judgments

Feast of Tabernacles Sermon by John W. Ritenbaugh

Multiple billions of people have lived and died without even hearing the name of Jesus Christ. But God has distinct periods of judgment and resurrection.