Keeping holy days in a carnal manner occurs when attendance at the Feast of Tabernacles serves mainly as an opportunity to escape work, or seek amusement. Excessive focus on outside activities and entertainment over God's purposes distracts from hearing His messages and fellowshipping with members of His Family. Ancient Israel rejoiced during the Feast but accomplished nothing God intended because idolatry corrupted their practices. Their offerings falsely indicated devotion while justice and true fellowship were absent. Without the sin offering they showed no recognition of spiritual poverty. Their joy had the wrong focus and produced no lasting appreciation of God's faithfulness.

Playlist:

playlist Go to the Holy Days, Kept in a Carnal Manner (topic) playlist

Filter by Categories

The Feast: Vacation or Holy Time?

CGG Weekly by Mark Schindler

At this time of year, we must reflect on our commitment to God and the purpose of keeping the Feast of Tabernacles and all the holy days He has consecrated for our benefit and to His honor and glory. While the Feast may have aspects of a vacation—being away from home, free from work or school, with extra money, staying at a hotel, eating out, and engaging in unusual activities—its purpose is far more serious and spiritual. We must ask ourselves if we truly believe and display our conviction by sharing this holy time with the Father, the Son, and one another in the way and place God has determined for us to serve Him and our brethren. Though factors such as age, health, and unforeseen, insurmountable difficulties may make attendance difficult or impossible, we must not let physical circumstances dictate our actions without diligently seeking God's will to avoid failing in our duty to appear before Him. Just as the Sabbath is not optional holy time, neither are God's holy days. We must examine ourselves to ensure our deceptive hearts have not demoted God's solemn and holy time to a mere elective. When God calls a holy convocation of His people, we should do our utmost to be there, recognizing that these feast days are set apart by Him to be observed as He commands, helping us to become holy as He is holy.

Holy Convocations

Sermonette by Ronny H. Graham

The term "holy convocation" is repeated ten times in Leviticus 23, indicating that God places utmost importance on fellowship with siblings in the faith.

Holy as He is Holy

Sermonette by Ronny H. Graham

Becoming holy is a process that spans an entire lifetime, which includes embracing God's holy days and tithes. Becoming holy takes continuous practice

The Feast Is Coming!

CGG Weekly by John O. Reid

Treating attendance at the Feast of Tabernacles primarily as a chance to get away from work or to amuse oneself constitutes keeping holy days in a carnal manner. Placing too much emphasis on outside activities and entertainment over God's purposes for His Feasts distracts from hearing His messages and fellowshipping with members of His Family. Complaining or murmuring during the festival season represents the opposite of fearing God and rejoicing before Him.

Feast: Command of God?

Sermonette by Ronny H. Graham

Keeping God's annual Sabbaths are just as much a mandate on God's people as keeping the Ten Commandments.

Fearing God at the Feast (Part Three)

CGG Weekly by David C. Grabbe

Ancient Israel was skilled at rejoicing during the Feast but did so in vain, failing to accomplish what God intended. Their festivities were rejected despite offerings and songs because idolatry, especially Molech worship, corrupted their practices and destroyed proper relationships with God and man. Burnt offerings falsely signaled wholehearted devotion while justice was absent. Meal offerings suggested dedication to others that did not exist. Peace offerings claimed fellowship that could not occur amid false worship. The drink offering representing life-expending service was omitted because self-centered enjoyment left no interest in serving brethren. The sin offering was also absent, indicating no recognition of spiritual poverty or need for forgiveness. Their joy had the wrong focus and was not governed by fear of God. They attended merely to have a good time while putting on a show of piety, then returned home unchanged to continue idolatry, injustice, and unrighteousness. Their pretense at communing with God produced no lasting appreciation of His faithfulness.

Rejoice and Serve!

Sermonette by Bill Onisick

Consuming second tithe (not within our gates) is understood to be for foodstuffs, for entertaining spiritual siblings, and making them happy and joyful.

Amos 5 and the Feast

Sermon by John W. Ritenbaugh (1932-2023)

Just because we keep God's feasts does not necessarily mean we are in sync with God's Law or intent. The Israelites kept the feasts in a carnal manner.

Is 'I AM' Truly the Lord Your God?

Sermon by Mark Schindler

When Jesus was asked to acknowledge His physical family, He responded that those who yield to the Father's direction are His real family.

Amos 5 and the Feast of Tabernacles

Sermon by John W. Ritenbaugh

If we go to the Feast with the goal of physically enjoying, we may lose out on both the spiritual and physical benefits. 'Going through the motions' defiles it.

The Sacred Assemblies

Sermonette by David C. Grabbe

The Last Day of Unleavened Bread and the Eighth Day are the only designated "sacred assemblies," which require a greater degree of solemnity for reflection.

Are the Blood Moons Significant? (Part Three)

CGG Weekly by David C. Grabbe

It is unusual for lunar eclipses to occur on God's holy days. Understanding those days helps us to find the right significance to the blood moons.

Amos 5 and the Feast of Tabernacles

'Personal' from John W. Ritenbaugh

How can we evaluate whether our Feast is 'good' or not? God's criticism of Israel's feasts in Amos 5 teaches what God wants us to learn from His feasts.

Whatsoever Your Heart Desires

Sermonette by Mark Schindler

We must not construe the term, "whatever our heart desires," as a pass to sin, but we should use every occasion to grow in thinking and acting like God.

Rejoice in God's Feast

Sermon by John W. Ritenbaugh

Preparing for the Feast of Tabernacles begins with understanding that God's rejoicing is not limited to happy, exuberant moments but includes the satisfaction He feels even when administering painful judgment for the sake of ultimate good, as seen in Deuteronomy 28 and 30. This foundation matters because rejoicing at the Feast is commanded as a choice and discipline, not merely a spontaneous emotional response, since the Hebrew word for rejoice suggests a momentary brightening tied to God or His ways rather than sustained happiness. A crucial preparatory principle is that the Feast does not occur in a vacuum. Amos 5 demonstrates that Israel's prosperity coexisted with moral corruption, and God rejected their feast days because their conduct throughout the year contaminated their worship. This shows that one's attitudes and behavior leading up to the Feast directly shape the experience at the Feast itself; one cannot separate daily conduct from festival observance. Personal reflection on a particularly unsatisfying Feast in 1974 illustrates this principle. Having no spiritual or physical responsibility, no arrangements to fellowship with others, and being consumed with personal interests like visiting family, sightseeing, and travel produced spiritual emptiness rather than rejoicing, despite pleasant physical circumstances. The lesson drawn is that the Feast is not a vacation, and self-focused attendance—giving nothing—results in leaving spiritually empty. Numbers 29 reveals that God required more sacrifices for the Feast of Tabernacles than for all other feasts combined, indicating that sacrifice—giving oneself at cost for others' benefit—is central to this Feast's meaning. Since sacrifice is the essence of love, and Deuteronomy 12 and 16 repeatedly link rejoicing with sacrificing before God in community with family, servants, Levites, strangers, orphans, and widows, true preparation involves cultivating a mindset of giving rather than self-gratification. Psalm 126 provides a symbolic picture: worshippers bringing sheaves represent sharing the fruit of labor and God's blessing with others. Preparation for the Feast, then, means bringing not only material offerings but spiritual fruit—the fruit of the Spirit described in Galatians 5, including love, joy, peace, and kindness—cultivated throughout the year, and deliberately sharing it with fellow worshippers through bearing one another's burdens, as instructed in Galatians 6. Ezekiel 36 extends this preparation into the Millennium itself, showing that God's cleansing and gift of a new heart require human cooperation to produce fruit; the Feast, as a small-scale picture of that future age, similarly demands the use of tools God has given to overcome inevitable problems with the right attitude rather than bitterness or self-pity. Since God commands rejoicing, this proves the attitude is subject to human will and must be actively produced, not passively expected. Ultimately, preparing for the Feast means resolving to imitate God's character of outgoing concern, giving, serving, and sacrificing, offering oneself in practical service, prayer, and generosity toward others, so that the Feast becomes a genuine demonstration of love for God rather than self-serving indulgence.

Tabernacles and Unleavened Bread (2019)

Sermonette by David C. Grabbe

Both Tabernacles and Unleavened Bread keep us off balance so that we remain humble, seek stability, and trust in God's providence for our ultimate destiny.

Are These Your Feasts? (Part Two)

CGG Weekly by Mark Schindler

When a famine of the Word covers the land, only a few have the God-given free-moral agency to choose to be fed the truth. Are we making the proper choices?

Amos (Part Nine)

Sermon/Bible Study by John W. Ritenbaugh

Ancient Israel regarded Bethel, Gilgal, and Beersheba as a sacred shrines, but were not becoming spiritually transformed as a result of pilgrimages.

Looking Back to the Future

Feast of Tabernacles Sermon by John W. Ritenbaugh

The dwelling in booths and the sacrifices were the context for rejoicing at the Feast of Tabernacles. The booths depict our current lives as pilgrims.

Amos (Part Eight)

Sermon/Bible Study by John W. Ritenbaugh

Amos severely chides Israel for exalting symbolism over substance, superstitiously trusting in locations where significant historical events occurred.

Amos (Part Ten)

Sermon/Bible Study by John W. Ritenbaugh

God requires a higher standard of righteous behavior from those who have consciously made a covenant with Him and are acquainted with His Law.

The Handwriting Is on the Wall (2021)

Feast of Tabernacles Sermon by Mark Schindler

Holy days can be kept in a carnal manner when God is left out of them. An advertisement for "Succoth at Disneyland Resort" offered theme-park rides, fireworks, concerts, singles matchmaking, medical-credit conferences, and kosher cuisine, yet God was missing from it; the focus was on the Jewish people and Israel, and Succoth became just a nice vacation. This is the way of Belshazzar, who profaned the holy things of God by drinking from the temple vessels and gave no glory to the God who holds his breath in His hands. The Feast of Tabernacles is a God-commanded assembly in which to rejoice before Him and give Him glory, with Christ as its focal point. Carnal men with hardened hearts have short memories. Even Israel did not keep the Feast with the right fervor until the returned captives in Nehemiah's day, released by another miraculous deliverance, kept it with very great gladness, having studied the Law. Veiled minds in the world, and even among the Jews, see only a holiday. Those called now behold God's glory with unveiled faces and are being transformed. They must therefore examine whether they come before Him clean and whether they are walking in the path, and use the Feast to see that their focus is on Christ, on becoming holy as He is holy, and on learning to serve.

Do You See God Working in You?

Sermon by Kim Myers

Job was able to endure the multiple trials and tragic events by seeing the hand of God in his life, realizing that God works in both good and bad times.

Teachings from Tabernacles

Feast of Tabernacles Sermon by David C. Grabbe

The temporary dwellings remind us that nothing earthly is permanent nor our true inheritance, and that our focus must be on what God is doing.