Filter by Categories
The Resurrection Was Not on Sunday
Herbert W. Armstrong BookletJesus' only sign of Messiahship was that He would spend three days and three nights in the grave (Matthew 12:39-40), which the Bible defines as a full 72 hours, as with Jonah (Jonah 1:17) and the Genesis day-and-night reckoning. Other texts such as Mark 8:31, Matthew 27:63, and John 2:19-21 confirm the same span, so a Friday sunset to Sunday sunrise burial cannot satisfy it. Because the tomb stay had to be exactly 72 hours, the resurrection occurred at the same time of day as the burial, which was late afternoon before sunset. The Sabbath after the crucifixion was the annual high-day Sabbath of the 15th of Abib (John 19:14, 31), not the weekly Sabbath. Jesus was crucified on Passover, Wednesday, and buried before sunset that day. Matthew 28:1 in the Greek speaks of "Sabbaths" in the plural, and Mark 16:1 with Luke 23:56 shows the women bought spices after the first Sabbath and rested on the weekly Sabbath, so two Sabbaths fell that week. Jesus therefore rose late Saturday afternoon, and the women found the tomb already empty on Sunday morning (Matthew 28:6, "He is risen, as he said"). Mark 16:9 uses the perfect tense, "was risen," and Luke 24:21 counts from Thursday's sealing of the tomb, so neither supports a Sunday resurrection. The Good Friday-Easter Sunday view is a tradition that nullifies the plain word of Scripture.
Was Jesus Resurrected on Easter Sunday?
'Ready Answer' by StaffJesus did not rise on Easter Sunday; He was crucified on Wednesday, Abib/Nisan 14, and rose about 72 hours later as the weekly Sabbath ended. Tradition assumes that Passover is a Sabbath, that all Sabbaths fall on the seventh day, and that the preparation day can only be Friday. Scripture shows otherwise. Passover is a feast but not a Sabbath, while the first and last days of Unleavened Bread (the fifteenth and twenty-first) are annual Sabbaths that cannot both fall on Saturday. A preparation day therefore precedes any Sabbath, weekly or annual. Luke's account confirms two preparation days that week: the women prepared spices after the holy day, then rested on the weekly Sabbath. Jesus' sign was Jonah's: "three days and three nights in the heart of the earth" (Matthew 12:40). With twelve hours of day and twelve of night (John 11:9), this means 72 hours, not a rabbinical reckoning of partial days. Since God the Father raised Him, in "the twinkling of an eye," the timing was exact. Counting back 72 hours from a Sunday dawn would reach Thursday, yet He was buried at sunset. The triumphal entry into Jerusalem, six days before Passover (John 12:1) plus one day, also undermines a Palm Sunday and a Friday crucifixion. Mary Magdalene found the tomb already empty while it was still dark on Sunday. Rising on Sunday would mean failing the one sign of His Messiahship.
Did Christ's Resurrection Change the Day of Worship? (Part One)
CGG Weekly by David C. GrabbeProtestants justify Sunday worship as a tradition honoring the day Christ rose, but this widespread assumption is wrong for two reasons. First, Scripture gives no record, implication, or hint that God removed the sanctification of the seventh day and transferred it to another. Second, the timing of the resurrection has nothing to do with establishing which day is holy and everything to do with proving that Jesus was the Messiah, a point reserved for a follow-up discussion. Claiming the Sabbath changed implies that the Creator is changeable, yet James 1:17 says there is no variation or shadow of turning with God, and Hebrews 13:8 says Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today, and forever. God's changelessness guards against false teaching. The Sabbath was the capstone of creation, set apart so that people could fellowship with God as He creates His spiritual image in them. It predates the Old Covenant, has its own perpetual covenant (Exodus 31:12-17), and stands outside the temporary Old Covenant. Jesus kept it, and His disputes with the Pharisees concerned how to keep it, never whether or when. The apostles and Gentile believers kept it after His death, and prophecy shows it observed in the Kingdom. Nothing in Scripture suggests that Christ's death, resurrection, or ascension modified the holiness God gave the seventh day.
Did Christ's Resurrection Change the Day of Worship? (Part Two)
CGG Weekly by David C. GrabbeChrist's resurrection did not change the day of worship, and it did not occur on Sunday. Protestant theologians justify Sunday worship by honoring the day of the resurrection, yet nothing in Scripture indicates God intended such a change. The timing of the resurrection matters for a different reason: in Matthew 12:38-40 Jesus gave only one sign that He was the Messiah, that He would be in the grave three days and three nights, as Jonah was in the great fish. That means 72 hours, and it cannot fit between a Friday afternoon and a Sunday morning. The traditional Friday-to-Sunday view therefore invalidates the very sign Jesus gave. Jesus was killed on Passover, the preparation day for an annual high-day Sabbath, the first day of Unleavened Bread (John 19:31), not the weekly Sabbath. In the year of His crucifixion Passover fell on a Wednesday, so He was buried late Wednesday afternoon and rose on Saturday, the weekly Sabbath, before sunset, fulfilling three days and three nights. Even so, His rising did not make that day holy, since it was already set apart. Even if the resurrection did establish a day of worship, it would be the seventh day. Sunday-keeping is thus a tradition of men that nullifies God's commandment (Matthew 15:6), while Scripture shows the Sabbath will be kept again when Christ returns.
What Makes This a 'Good' Friday?
CGG Weekly by Richard T. RitenbaughJesus' resurrection did not occur on Sunday. He defined His burial as exactly 72 hours, no more and no less. His one sign of Messiahship was three days and three nights in the heart of the earth (Matthew 12:38-40), and three days and three nights are six twelve-hour periods (John 11:9-10). His other statements, "in three days," "the third day," and "after three days" (John 2:19-21; Mark 8:31; 9:31), together box the burial into exactly 72 hours. Counting back 72 hours from a Sunday dawn resurrection lands on Thursday daybreak, yet Scripture says Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus laid Jesus in the tomb as the sun was setting (Mark 15:42-46; John 19:39-41). No span from sunset to sunrise can equal 72 hours, so a Sunday morning resurrection cannot be true. Buried at sunset, Jesus had to rise at sunset. The Gospels do not record the moment of the resurrection, only when His followers first found the tomb empty early Sunday, by which time He had been gone about twelve hours. Daniel 9:27 places the crucifixion in the middle of the week. Christ confirmed the New Covenant and ended sacrifice and offering by His once-for-all offering (Hebrews 9:23-28), so He died on Wednesday. He was entombed late that day at sunset and rose exactly 72 hours later, at sundown as the seventh-day Sabbath ended. Good Friday and Easter Sunday therefore contradict the biblical record, and Friday is only a Preparation Day.
In the Heart of the Earth
CGG Weekly by Richard T. RitenbaughJesus was not crucified on Good Friday and raised on Easter Sunday; Scripture supports a full 72-hour burial from Wednesday at sunset to the weekly Sabbath at sunset. "Three days and three nights" (Matthew 12:40) means a complete 72 hours, not parts of three days. John 20:1 says only that Mary Magdalene came to the tomb on the first day of the week while it was still dark, and Jesus was already gone, so the verse does not mark the moment of the resurrection. The disciples' remark on the Emmaus road, "Today is the third day since these things happened" (Luke 24:21), is not a contradiction, since "The Scripture cannot be broken" (John 10:35). Either they were summing up the whole string of events of that week, the last being the setting of the guard on the tomb on Thursday or early Friday, or, most naturally, they meant that the sign's third day had already passed and their hopes were dashed. The phrase "in the heart of the earth" does not mean Jerusalem as the center of the nations. Drawn from Jonah 2:2-3, where the heart of the seas parallels the belly of Sheol, it is a Hebrew metaphor for being dead and buried. John 2:19-21 confirms that the sign concerns the destruction of the temple of His body. Jesus spoke of His death, burial, and resurrection, not of His travel plans.
'After Three Days'
Booklet by Richard T. RitenbaughJesus did not die on Friday and rise on Sunday. He died about 3 PM on a Wednesday, Passover, Nisan 14, in AD 31, and was buried at sunset. God raised Him exactly 72 hours later, at sunset as the weekly Sabbath ended. The only sign Jesus gave of His Messiahship was the sign of Jonah: three days and three nights in the heart of the earth (Matthew 12:38-40). Jesus Himself defined a day as twelve hours of light and a night as twelve hours of darkness (John 11:9-10; Genesis 1:5-13), so three days and three nights is 72 hours, and a Friday-to-Sunday span cannot contain it. His phrases "after three days," "in three days," and "the third day" all fit exactly 72 hours. Two Sabbaths fell in that period: the high-day Sabbath of the first day of Unleavened Bread on Thursday, and the weekly Sabbath. The women bought spices after the first Sabbath, on Friday, and rested on the second (Mark 16:1; Luke 23:56). Matthew 28:1 literally reads "after the Sabbaths." Daniel's Seventy Weeks prophecy points to the middle of the week and to AD 31, and the four Passovers of the gospels confirm a three-and-a-half-year ministry. Verses like Luke 24:21, Matthew 27:64, and Mark 16:9 do not contradict this. Good Friday, Easter Sunday, and the claim that the resurrection changed the Sabbath to Sunday rest on a false chronology and are therefore false worship.
Chronic Difficulties
Sermon by Richard T. RitenbaughJesus was not resurrected on Sunday morning; the tradition of a Friday crucifixion and Easter Sunday resurrection does not square with Scripture. Jesus was crucified on a Wednesday, Passover, Nisan 14, and Joseph of Arimathea laid Him in the tomb just before sunset, as the annual Sabbath of the first Day of Unleavened Bread began. Passover is always a preparation day for that holy day, and a preparation day need not be a Friday. Jesus Himself prophesied in Matthew 12:40, using the sign of Jonah, that He would be in the heart of the earth three days and three nights. Gospel phrases such as "in three days," "the third day," and "after three days" are satisfied only by exactly 72 hours. Counting three full days from late Wednesday near sunset brings the resurrection to the end of the weekly Sabbath near sunset, not to Sunday. The women could not have prepared spices on the holy day without breaking it, so they bought and prepared them on Friday, between the two Sabbaths that week, rested on the weekly Sabbath, and came to the tomb early Sunday. None of the Gospels says He rose that morning. Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John all report that the women found the stone rolled away and the tomb already empty, and the angel said, "He is risen, as He said." He had already been raised about twelve hours or a little more.
He Lives, We Live
Sermon by Richard T. RitenbaughJesus was not raised at Sunday dawn. Matthew 28:1 gives the time the women came to the tomb, not the time of the resurrection. The angel's words, "He has risen," use a Greek simple past, meaning the action was already completed, as the NRSV ("He has been raised") and the Holman Christian Standard Bible ("He has been resurrected") render it. Mark 16:9 is likewise mistranslated in many versions. The Greek anastas, an aorist participle, means "having risen," an action completed before the main verb "appeared." So Jesus had already been raised before He appeared to Mary Magdalene early on the first day, as the NET and Holman translations correctly show. The Greek gives no specific time for the resurrection itself. Jesus was placed in the tomb at sunset and was to remain three full days and three nights, 72 hours, so He could not have risen in the morning or near dawn. He rose at sunset, the evening before the women arrived. The Easter sunrise service therefore commemorates a wrong day and time, and the name Easter, from the fertility goddess Eoster, along with its eggs, bunnies, and hot cross buns, has pagan origins that no appeal to children or tradition can make Christian. Still, the timing matters far less than the purpose of the resurrection. Because Christ lives, believers are saved by His life, have hope of eternal life, and receive His power through the Spirit to overcome.
The Plain Truth About Easter
Herbert W. Armstrong BookletThe resurrection of Jesus Christ did not occur on Sunday, contrary to widespread belief. For 1600 years, the Western world has been taught that Christ rose from the dead on Sunday morning, but this is not accurate. The true timing of His resurrection aligns with the observance of Passover, not the pagan festival later called Easter. Jesus, the early apostles, and the converted Gentile Christians observed Passover on the 14th day of the first month of the sacred calendar, a date that varies from year to year and is not fixed to a specific day of the week. This practice was maintained by the early true Church as a memorial of Christ's crucifixion, occurring annually at a specific calendar time rather than on a designated day like Sunday.
'Seventy Weeks Are Determined...'
'Prophecy Watch' by Richard T. RitenbaughThe Seventy Weeks Prophecy of Daniel 9:24-27 dates Christ's death to the middle of the seventieth week, which rules out the traditional Good Friday and Easter Sunday. The seventy weeks begin with the decree of Artaxerxes I in 457 BC, the return under Ezra. Sixty-nine weeks, or 483 years, bring the count to AD 27, when John baptized Jesus and His ministry began. Messiah would be cut off in the middle of the seventieth week, and halfway through a prophetic week is three and a half years, the length of His ministry. That brings the crucifixion to AD 31, when Passover, Nisan 14, fell on a Wednesday, literally the middle of a week. Those who count from 444 BC with a 360-day year and arrive at AD 33 do so by a contrived method. They are two years off, since Jeremiah's seventy years were literal and Gabriel's weeks of years should be taken just as plainly. They also err in treating the triumphal entry as Messiah's proclamation, because the Father proclaimed Him at His baptism. Because a Wednesday crucifixion fits the prophecy, Good Friday and Easter cannot stand before these facts. The prophecy also shows that Christ's death was not for Himself but for mankind's redemption, and that it ended the need for animal sacrifices.